The true stories of people who lived with a killer. How well do you really know your family? Would you recognize the warning signs? Or would you become entangled in evil?
Season 5 – Episode 10
Aziza Ayinde Kibbibi, the daughter of “Fugees” music video director Aswad Ayinde, discusses how after suffering years of sexual abuse at the hands of her polygamist father, she was able to survive and finally escape to reveal the truth about him.
The episode was rated from 38 votes.
#2 – The Grim Reaper
Season 4 – Episode 7
Linda is overjoyed after finding out that family friend Greg Scarpa is her biological father; when Scarpa’s secrets come out, Linda realizes that being part of his family is not only dangerous, it is potentially deadly.
The episode was rated from 40 votes.
#3 – It Was All Judith
Season 7 – Episode 1
As a child, Corey Breininger’s stepmother, Judith Hawkey, coerces him into doing something horrible; he keeps her deadly secret for years, too afraid to tell anyone the truth.
The episode was rated from 54 votes.
#4 – My Twisted Sister
Season 6 – Episode 8
When Elizabeth Flores was a child, her sister, Louise, tried to shield her from a horrible family secret; when Louise met David Turpin, that all changed.
The episode was rated from 50 votes.
#5 – Fear Thy Father
Season 4 – Episode 4
Charles Sexton believes his father, Eddie, is God; he and his siblings are loyal disciples until the family descends into madness, and Sexton finds out that crossing his parents means death.
The episode was rated from 41 votes.
#6 – Thicker Than Blood
Season 4 – Episode 9
The episode was rated from 18 votes.
#7 – I Don’t Believe in Forgiveness
Season 8 – Episode 3
Teri Knight spent weeks driving cross-country, desperately searching for the secret her ex-husband, Manuel Gehring, took to his grave. It took years before a stranger finally solved the mystery that haunted Teri ever since learning Manuel died in prison.
The episode was rated from 26 votes.
#8 – Something Wasn’t Right
Season 4 – Episode 5
When Reginald Brooks begins acting strangely, Beverly Stephens worries that her husband’s bizarre behavior is a warning sign that something wasn’t right, but never suspected there was a killer lurking inside him.
The episode was rated from 47 votes.
#9 – In the Lion’s Cage
Season 4 – Episode 2
Linda Wittmier and Terry Jo Howard fall in love with James Michael Randall; both of them discover the monster lurking inside him without ever realizing how lucky they were to survive his twisted desire to kill.
The episode was rated from 46 votes.
#10 – The Nights I Don’t Remember
Season 7 – Episode 3
Travis Spencer thinks that the cruel pranks played by his older brother, Timothy, were ultimately harmless; it turns out that older brother Timothy is using younger brother Travis as practice for a gruesome future.
The episode was rated from 39 votes.